As his enemy's sword draws closer, Wyl finally understands the meaning of Myrren's dying words, and he wonders: had he known what that one act of kindness would bring, would he have behaved otherwise? Gripping the reader from the very first page, Myrren's Gift marks Fiona McIntosh as one of fantasy fiction's most gifted storytellers. This was too generic for me. The plot is basically reusable for any fantasy author out there. Cue pointless journey and dogs appearing out of nowhere to help whenever a fight doesn't It started off with potential, but pretty much destroyed it later on.
Cue pointless journey and dogs appearing out of nowhere to help whenever a fight doesn't go the good guy's way. Now the above is all well and good, but for the fact that both sides figure complex plans to simple problems and never listen to warnings, ever.
It was honestly too frustrating to finish slogging through. Sep 08, Kristi-anne rated it it was amazing.
I don't know why so many bad reviews, I found this trilogy awesome, I couldn't stop reading it, I couldn't put it down till done such awesome twists , I loved it!!! Jul 14, Dead Stuff rated it did not like it. Myrren's Gift is a brilliant example of how treating the text as unreliable improves it beyond measure. This could be the story of Celimus, a boy born into a tragic fate he cannot hope to uphold. His mother has been forced into an arranged marriage with a much older king to secure trading rights, not for love.
Refusing to bend her will, she raises her son to be brilliant, ruthless and stand up to his father Too late Myrren's Gift is a brilliant example of how treating the text as unreliable improves it beyond measure. Too late, his father has his mother assassinated. But the boy is already old enough to hear whispers, and soon discovers he will never be able to trust his father. The two mens' paths diverge. Seeking to assert his flagging manhood, the King of Morgravia stokes the fire of war anew with the neighboring nation.
Obediently, General Thirsk and his son Wyl ride off to battle, only for the General to throw his life away! Reaching out for the son he feels he never had, the King does not allow Wyl Thirsk to be sent off to a military academy. Instead, the King keeps Wyl close by at court, and the bond between king and prince is forever sundered. Prince Celimus,for his part, clings to religion to give himself some direction.
Witches, with their inhuman abilities to resist pain and their terrible curses, could have been treated as very real threats to the security of Morgravia.
Blood and Memory: The Quickening Book Two
When Celimus' agents find one, the witch curses Wyl with heterochromia and To protect himself, and to give Wyl Thirsk the training he needs if he is to lead the Morgravian army, Celimus wisely sends his new general off to the mysterious northern border Heck, she isn't even Danielle Steele. The whole story is played tragically straight. If you're the author's favorite, you are good, noble and pure; if you're one of the author's targets, you are irredeemable.
To motivate myself, I took a drink of scotch every time I found a proper name with the letter Y in it. I got drunk around page and gave the rest of the book up. Mar 18, Lisa H. What a damn lie.
See a Problem?
Hobb is an amazing writer and I can't imagine she would honestly rave about this trite piece of barely-adequate crap. I should know better than ever go by rave author blurbs except Harlan Ellison. I think Ellison would be outraged by the idea of puffing a book he didn't actually like. Secondly, the transparently telegraphed set ups - i. I know! I am just as stunned as you are. And there's a fucking magical dog. Which understands human speech and can communicate on a rudimentary level like barking once as confirmation.
Myrren''''s Gift (The Quickening, Book 1)
And apparently can on occasion transport itself from point to point. And may be able to transport humans in a similar fashion, although the details are still murky on that. The dog's abilities are becoming more numerous as the story goes on. It's fantasy Lassie, man. And there there's a mass of piddly little kvetches, like using the word "boon" twice in one paragraph, and the second time it's not even really the right word. The more I think about it the more I think two stars is overly generous. In some respects, Myrren's Gift is an average fantasy romp with everything you'd expect in a fantasy novel; court intrigue, battles, magic, a bit of romance etc etc.
At times it's just a little tedious because it feels like I've read all of this stuff before. Certain charters seem to lack depth, and perhaps also intelligence, and it is frustrating to watch said characters trying to solve problems when the answer is so, so obvious.
- Auto Repair For Dummies?
- MYRREN'S GIFT: The Quickening Book One?
- Literary Terms and Criticism: A Students’ Guide.
- Play the French, 3rd (Cadogan Chess Books);
- Your Chinese Horoscope 2009: What the Year of the Ox Holds in Store for You.
However, the book certainly isn't terrible. There are well writte In some respects, Myrren's Gift is an average fantasy romp with everything you'd expect in a fantasy novel; court intrigue, battles, magic, a bit of romance etc etc. I especially enjoyed reading of Wyl's time in the Mountain Kingdom. Of course, the concept of the Gift itself is also an interesting and original one, and I look forward to seeing how this magic unravels in the next two books. May 17, Nita rated it did not like it. I was silly enough to buy all three books at once and so i read or skimmed when i just could not take it anymore the whole series.
I'd give it less if i could. I recommend it to no one. Aug 26, Katilian rated it did not like it Shelves: fantasy. The concept behind this series is an interesting one. Unfortunately, the execution is weak. The three-book plot relies on character stupidity to keep it going, and the prose reads like a Harlequin parody.
- Love and Compassion?
- Storm Warning: Deceptive Evil Looms on the Horizon;
- Hellboy Wild Hunt #7.
- Bone Densitometry for Technologists.
- Unusual prophecies being fulfilled : the pope, the eagle and the iron sickle;
- Joshua, Act 1, Nos. 5 So long the memory shall last.
- Shout For The Dead: The Acendants of Estorea 2 (The Ascendants of Estorea)?
I kept reading mainly to see how bad it could get. Nov 06, Martin Owton rated it did not like it.
A strong contender for the worst book from a major publisher I've ever read. Chock full of poor characterisation, point of view shifts, redundant plot threads and improbable twists. Mar 26, Jenny rated it did not like it Shelves: own-it. Things I liked: - somewhat exciting plot - somewhat colourful characters Things I didn't like: - McIntosh's portrayal of female characters as in need of male guidance and protection. Even Valentyna, a strong and capable woman who really doesn't need anyone's help, constantly has all these men looking out for her and protecting her, but it's not really clear why they are more capable at looking after Valentyna's safety than she would be.
Myrren's Gift (The Quickening, Book 1) - AbeBooks - Fiona McIntosh:
And Ylena, what is the deal with her? Despite being of a marri Things I liked: - somewhat exciting plot - somewhat colourful characters Things I didn't like: - McIntosh's portrayal of female characters as in need of male guidance and protection. Despite being of a marriable age, she seems to be about eight years old considering how much her older brother coddles her. It's like it's a totally normal thing and not at all traumatising, scary or sickening.
Like when Lothren spends a day crying because his wife has died in childbirth and then forgets everything about her and instead becomes his old grumpy self. The only male who isn't a macho type of dude is our dear Fynch, an awkward child. It is SO boring and uncreative. I mean, I totally get where he's coming from. His mother was married off to some king who was older than she and who forced himself on her. She obviously developed a hatred for the guy and inevitably passed this on to her son who never enjoyed any attention from his father.
Instead, the king basically adopts his best friend the general's son. Celimus is jealous of this other boy who somehow has managed to win the affections of his father and a rivalry develops. Yet Celimus is demonised and I felt like the author didn't even try to show any nuances in Celimus's behaviour; everything was just evil and cruel. I'm not defending Celimus because to be fair he is a bit awful, but he's such a Disney villain.
He's got no depth and no motivation - he's just a bad person.
- OLEDs for lighting?
- Thailands Islands & Beaches (Regional Guide);
- Myrren's Gift.
- Breakdown of Will.
- Blood and Memory: The Quickening Book Two;
- BookLoons Reviews - Myrren's Gift by Fiona McIntosh.
Wyl, however, is THE golden boy. He is great at fighting, leading his troops and also a great person, despite being ugly and having no parents. Because he is such a good leader and warrior he earned the respect of his army immediately? He is also sexually innocent there are very strong connections between morality and sexuality in this book, just compare to the morally dubious Romen and his sexual prowess.
Aug 19, Doc rated it did not like it Recommends it for: No oneI. I've had to change my position on book burning after reading this orc entrails and tripe. I was dragged, jerked and jolted for 75 pages of agonizing uncharismatic characters, weak premise and terrible dialogue. Luckily,before too much self torture; I did some reconnaissance on this affliction i was reading and found, many poor souls had suffered far further reading then i and came to the same conclusion. Save yourself, your bra I've had to change my position on book burning after reading this orc entrails and tripe.
Save yourself, your brain cells, and the suffering. It is that bad. Shelves: books-read Just when I thought I had Fiona Mcintosh all figured out, she gives me this jaw-breaking twist that ended the life of one of my favorite characters- which in turn led to the throwing of the hardbound copy of this damn book! Yeah yeah.